Mon Dec 01 14:20:00 UTC 2025: Summary:

The 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has ruled that Alina Habba, a Trump loyalist and former personal lawyer for the president, is unlawfully serving as Acting U.S. Attorney for the District of New Jersey. The ruling upholds a lower court decision and strikes a blow against Trump’s efforts to install his preferred nominees in U.S. attorney’s offices in blue states without Senate approval. The court questioned the unconventional manner in which Habba was reinstalled after her initial, temporary appointment expired. Habba’s situation is part of a broader legal challenge to Trump’s use of loopholes in federal vacancy laws to appoint U.S. attorneys without Senate confirmation, particularly in states where Democratic senators are unlikely to approve them through the “blue slip” tradition.

News Article:

Court Rules Trump Appointee Habba Unlawfully Serving as NJ Prosecutor

Trenton, NJ – A federal appeals court has ruled that Alina Habba, a staunch Trump ally and former personal attorney for the ex-president, is unlawfully serving as Acting U.S. Attorney for the District of New Jersey, dealing a significant setback to the former administration’s efforts to place loyalists in top prosecutorial roles in states with Democratic opposition.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit upheld a lower court’s decision to disqualify Habba, siding with arguments that her appointment circumvented Senate confirmation processes. The ruling centers around the Trump administration’s unusual method of re-appointing Habba after her initial temporary appointment expired, prompting scrutiny from the court.

“The sequence of events here… appear to be a complete circumvention of the appointments clause,” one of the judges stated during oral arguments in October.

The case arose after defendants facing unrelated charges challenged Habba’s authority to prosecute them, arguing that she was not a validly appointed U.S. attorney. Habba’s path to Senate confirmation was blocked, in part due to the lack of support from New Jersey’s Democratic Senators, Cory Booker and Andy Kim, due to the Senate’s “blue slip” tradition, which allows home-state senators to effectively veto judicial and U.S. attorney nominees.

The Trump administration defended its actions, arguing that it was simply utilizing legal mechanisms afforded by Congress. However, the court appeared unconvinced.

The ruling comes amid broader legal challenges to several Trump-appointed U.S. attorneys serving on a temporary basis in states with Democratic senators, including Lindsey Halligan in Virginia and Bill Essayli in California. These challenges hinge on accusations that the administration exploited loopholes in federal vacancy laws to sidestep the Senate confirmation process.

The Department of Justice has not yet commented on whether it will seek a rehearing before the full Third Circuit or appeal the decision to the Supreme Court. The case raises serious questions about the balance of power between the executive and legislative branches in the appointment of key government officials.

Read More