Tue Jun 03 10:22:43 UTC 2025: ## Summary:

The Calcutta High Court granted bail to two men, Munna Dhali and Nabu Dhali, accused of a 2012 quadruple murder, citing their right to life under Article 21 of the Indian Constitution after being incarcerated for over 12 years without trial completion. The men, along with two others, are accused of murdering their employer, his mother, and two maids. One other accused had previously been granted bail on similar grounds, while another was denied. The court ordered the release of Munna and Nabu Dhali upon furnishing bonds and sureties, directing them to appear at every hearing and not to tamper with witnesses or evidence.

## News Article:

**Calcutta High Court Grants Bail to Quadruple Murder Accused After 12 Years Imprisonment**

**Kolkata, June 3, 2025** – The Calcutta High Court has granted bail to two men, Munna Dhali and Nabu Dhali, who have been in custody for over 12 years awaiting trial for a quadruple murder that occurred in 2012. The court cited Article 21 of the Indian Constitution, guaranteeing the right to life, as the basis for the decision, emphasizing the prolonged period of incarceration without a completed trial.

The Dhali brothers, along with two other individuals, are accused of murdering Dipak Bhattacharya, a local cable television business owner, his mother, and two maids at their residence in the Thakurpukur police station area of West Bengal.

Justice Suvra Ghosh, in her judgement delivered on May 15, stated the bail was granted “solely on the anvil of Article 21 of the Constitution of India” without addressing the merits of the case.

While another accused, Rajesh Das, was previously granted bail on similar grounds, the fourth accused, Sattar Mondal, was denied. The prosecution had promised to examine remaining witnesses by April, but the trial has seen no progress since February.

The court ordered the release of Munna and Nabu Dhali upon furnishing a bond of ₹10,000 each and providing two sureties, one of whom must be local. The accused have also been instructed to appear before the trial court on every hearing date and are forbidden from intimidating witnesses or tampering with evidence. The case remains open and is being closely monitored.

Read More