Mon Jan 13 05:40:00 UTC 2025: ## Cardinals’ Arenado Trade Remains Stalled Amidst Contract and Player Preferences
**St. Louis, MO (January 10, 2025)** – The St. Louis Cardinals’ attempts to trade veteran third baseman Nolan Arenado have hit a standstill, according to multiple reports. Arenado’s full no-trade clause, a recent offensive downturn, and a remaining three-year, $74 million contract (partially offset by the Colorado Rockies) have significantly complicated negotiations.
Arenado’s rejection of a proposed trade to the Houston Astros, who subsequently signed Christian Walker, highlighted the challenges. His agent stated Arenado only considers teams where he believes he can contend for a championship in both the short and long term.
The Boston Red Sox emerged as a potential suitor, but the deal remains complex. Acquiring Arenado would likely require shifting Rafael Devers to first base, displacing Triston Casas, who could then move to DH, although the Red Sox are committed to Masataka Yoshida in that role. Trading Casas would necessitate significant player returns from Boston, making the overall scenario uncertain.
The Athletic’s Katie Woo reports that the Cardinals are hesitant to absorb a substantial portion of Arenado’s contract, a key factor in their desire to reduce payroll. If a trade fails to materialize, the Cardinals may explore other avenues to trim payroll and acquire young talent.
Several Cardinals players, including Erick Fedde, Ryan Helsley, and Steven Matz, are free agents after the 2025 season and could be attractive trade pieces. The St. Louis Post-Dispatch suggests exploring trades for these players, possibly coupled with re-signing Kyle Gibson, to enhance the team’s long-term prospects.
While some outlets suggest a trade is increasingly unlikely, others offer a glimmer of hope. MLB.com’s John Denton indicates the Red Sox may withdraw from the Alex Bregman bidding, potentially increasing the chances of an Arenado deal. MLB Network’s Jon Morosi suggests Arenado is becoming more open-minded to potential trade partners, potentially reviving interest from teams previously deemed unsuitable.
However, financial constraints limit several teams’ ability to absorb Arenado’s substantial contract. The Kansas City Royals, for example, while showing initial interest, are deemed financially unlikely to make a trade.
Ultimately, the likelihood of an Arenado trade remains uncertain. While injuries or other market shifts could create unforeseen opportunities, the current situation points towards a potential long-term presence in St. Louis for the star third baseman. The Cardinals’ strategic choices regarding their roster will hinge on the outcome of these trade negotiations.
First Piper 