Sat Nov 16 00:09:06 UTC 2024: ## New Web Series “Freedom At Midnight” Offers Contentious Take on India’s Partition

**Mumbai, India** – A new seven-part web series, “Freedom At Midnight,” based on Larry Collins and Dominique Lapierre’s book of the same name, has premiered, sparking debate. While the creators claim to have used the book—written by authors not easily accused of pro-India or pro-Pakistan bias—as a foundation for a balanced portrayal, the series has already faced criticism for perceived omissions and its interpretation of historical events.

The series, directed by Nikkhil Advani, acknowledges taking “creative liberties” and fictionalizing certain aspects, stating it is not a documentary. This disclaimer highlights the challenges of adapting such a complex and emotionally charged period in history, particularly in today’s polarized climate. The review points out the source material itself simplifies the intricate details of the partition, and favors Lord Mountbatten, the last Viceroy of India.

The series focuses heavily on conversations between key figures like Nehru, Gandhi, Jinnah, and Patel, offering a largely static presentation despite acknowledging the scale and violence of the partition. While some performances are praised, particularly Arif Zakaria as Jinnah and Rajendra Chawla as Sardar Patel, others are deemed uneven, with some actors appearing miscast due to age discrepancies. The reviewer also criticizes the excessive background music, which often overshadows dialogue.

Ultimately, despite its shortcomings, the reviewer finds the series valuable for its attempt to revisit a crucial moment in history from the perspective of those fighting for freedom, though it ultimately falls short of profound historical analysis. The review concludes that the series, while not perfect, initiates crucial conversations about India and Pakistan’s independence and the lingering questions surrounding the true cost of freedom.

Read More