Thu Sep 19 09:00:00 UTC 2024: ## HUD Explores Replacing Housing Vouchers with Direct Cash Payments to Renters
The Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) is revisiting a decades-old idea – providing direct cash payments to renters instead of housing vouchers. While the voucher program has helped millions, it faces challenges, including lengthy waitlists, high rejection rates, and bureaucratic hurdles for landlords.
The idea of cash assistance has gained traction due to successful pandemic aid programs and basic income experiments. Philadelphia is already testing this approach, and HUD is seeking further research to explore its potential impact.
HUD’s move stems from a rediscovery of 1970s research on the subject, which was sidelined by the launch of the voucher program. However, the program’s limitations have spurred advocates and officials to consider alternatives.
“It’s taken us 50 years to come back to it and really experiment with it once again,” says Solomon Greene, a policy developer at HUD.
Challenges remain in implementing a direct cash system, including ensuring landlords’ compliance with safety inspections and preventing misuse of funds.
“There are some tricky things that agencies will have to go through when they do this,” says Brian McCabe of Georgetown University.
One potential solution is a self-inspection system, where tenants complete a checklist before moving in, followed by a remote inspection by housing authorities.
Researchers are particularly interested in exploring whether direct cash payments would help renters find housing faster and move to better neighborhoods.
“Will the whole process of leasing up happen more quickly?” asks James Riccio of MDRC, who is designing a pilot program in six cities. “Which could save time and money for the housing authority and certainly for tenants as well.”
HUD emphasizes that the new tests will take years to complete and any significant changes to the current voucher program would require congressional approval.
“Your cost burden goes down. You are more likely to be able to stay in your unit longer,” says Greene. “There’s a rich body of research showing that vouchers are the most effective way of preventing recidivism or returns to homelessness.”
However, he also acknowledges that “we don’t know” if direct cash payments could achieve the same results. HUD’s current focus is on gathering evidence to inform future policy decisions.
First Piper 