Thu Feb 26 06:20:00 UTC 2026: ### Broadway’s “All Out” Attempts to Redefine Theatrical Norms with Rotating Cast and Unique Format
The Story:
“All Out: Comedy About Ambition,” a new Broadway show written by Simon Rich and directed by Alex Timbers, is challenging traditional Broadway conventions. The show features a rotating cast of comedians, including notable names like Sarah Silverman, Heidi Gardner, Craig Robinson, and Beck Bennet, who perform short stories written by Rich. The opening night performance featured Jake Shane, Ray Romano, Nicholas Braun, and Jenny Slate, accompanied by original music from the band Lawrence. While the comedians and music received high praise, the review suggests the show’s disjointed narrative and unconventional structure may hinder its overall impact within the established Broadway landscape.
Key Points:
- “All Out” is written by Simon Rich and directed by Alex Timbers.
- The show features a rotating cast of comedians, including Sarah Silverman, Heidi Gardner, Craig Robinson, and Beck Bennet.
- The opening night cast included Jake Shane, Ray Romano, Nicholas Braun, and Jenny Slate.
- Original music is provided by the band Lawrence.
- The review highlights the show’s lack of a common narrative thread and inconsistent pacing.
- The reviewer notes that the actors read from books, which detracted from the experience.
- The reviewer suggests that a consistent cast and the addition of props or choreography could improve the show.
- The review considers that the show is geared towards an older audience looking for an elegant yet comedic night out.
Key Takeaways:
- “All Out” represents an attempt to introduce a more experimental, comedy-focused format to Broadway.
- The success of the show may depend on its ability to overcome the challenges associated with a rotating cast and a fragmented narrative.
- The show’s appeal may be limited to audiences seeking a departure from traditional Broadway musicals and productions.
First Piper 