Mon Feb 23 13:50:00 UTC 2026: ### Olympic Gold Divides: Eileen Gu Faces Scrutiny as Alysa Liu’s Patriotism Celebrated

The Story:

As Alysa Liu secured a historic Olympic gold for the U.S. in figure skating at the 2026 Milan Cortina Winter Olympics, the narrative quickly shifted to contrasting her story with that of Eileen Gu, the American-born skier competing for China. While Liu’s father’s escape from communist China is being hailed as a testament to American ideals, Gu faces increasing criticism for her choice to represent China, particularly amid ongoing concerns about the country’s human rights record. This juxtaposition has ignited a debate about loyalty, patriotism, and the complex choices faced by athletes with ties to both the U.S. and China.

Key Points:

  • Alysa Liu’s father, Arthur Liu, was a participant in the 1989 Tiananmen Square protests and later fled China, seeking refuge in the U.S.
  • Eileen Gu, born and raised in California, chose to represent China in freestyle skiing starting in June 2019.
  • Gu has faced criticism for her silence on China’s alleged human rights abuses, particularly regarding the Uyghur population.
  • Liu and her father were allegedly targeted by a Chinese spying operation before the 2022 Beijing Olympics due to his past activism.
  • Gu is the highest-paid Winter Olympic athlete, earning an estimated $23 million in 2025 through endorsements.
  • Alysa Liu has expressed interest in having her and her father’s experience with international spying be made into a movie.

Critical Analysis:

The provided historical context highlights a recurring theme: the scrutiny surrounding Eileen Gu’s decision to represent China. The juxtaposition with Alysa Liu’s American patriotism amplifies this scrutiny, particularly given the timing of Liu’s gold medal win. The contrast is strategically leveraged by some, like Dave Portnoy and Gordon Chang, to emphasize perceived ideological victories. This pattern reveals how the Olympics are not just about athletic competition but also serve as a stage for geopolitical narratives and the projection of national values.

Key Takeaways:

  • The Olympics can become a battleground for ideological narratives, particularly when athletes with dual national identities are involved.
  • Athletes’ choices regarding national representation are often interpreted through a political lens, regardless of their personal motivations.
  • The contrast between Alysa Liu’s and Eileen Gu’s stories highlights the complex relationship between the U.S. and China, and the challenges faced by individuals navigating both cultures.
  • Eileen Gu’s silence on human rights issues in China has intensified criticism, demonstrating the increasing pressure on athletes to take political stances.
  • Alysa Liu’s experience with the Chinese spying operation underscores the ongoing tensions and potential risks for individuals with ties to both countries.

    Read More