Sun Jan 25 08:30:00 UTC 2026: ### Highguard’s Game Awards Debut: Favor, Not Fortune, Fueled Controversial Launch

The Story:
The hero shooter game Highguard from Wildlight, comprised of Apex Legends and Titanfall veterans, faced a rocky start after its debut at The Game Awards 2025. Contrary to speculation, the prime finale slot wasn’t bought, but rather offered by showrunner Geoff Keighley, who reportedly liked the game. This revelation followed criticism of the game’s poorly received trailer and unconventional marketing strategy, including a complete social media blackout until launch day, January 26, 2026.

Despite the advantage of being a free-to-play title, Highguard’s generic trailer and the timing of its marketing campaign raised eyebrows in the gaming community. The game’s system requirements and the controversial requirement for Secure Boot to play further compounded concerns about its launch prospects.

Key Points:

  • Highguard received the finale slot at The Game Awards 2025 without payment.
  • Geoff Keighley reportedly offered the spot due to liking the game.
  • Highguard’s reveal trailer was poorly received.
  • The game’s marketing campaign started just a week before its January 26, 2026 release date.
  • Highguard is a free-to-play, “raid”-based shooter.
  • The game requires Secure Boot to play, stirring controversy.

Critical Analysis:
The events point to a high degree of risk on the part of both Wildlight and Geoff Keighley. For Wildlight, accepting the Game Awards spot represented a high-stakes gamble that backfired. The decision to postpone all marketing until just before launch indicates either a lack of resources, overconfidence, or a desperate attempt to salvage a project facing internal difficulties.
Geoff Keighley‘s decision to gift the coveted spot, based solely on personal preference, reflects a concerning lack of objectivity and potentially damaged the credibility of The Game Awards as a platform for unbiased promotion. The subsequent negative reception unfairly implicated Keighley.

Key Takeaways:

  • Relying on a single showcase event without a comprehensive marketing strategy can be detrimental, even with a prime placement.
  • Personal endorsements should not outweigh strategic considerations when allocating high-profile promotional opportunities.
  • Controversial system requirements can negatively impact a game’s reception, especially at launch.
  • The success of a game, even with experienced developers, is not guaranteed, and adequate marketing is crucial.
  • The free-to-play model offers a safety net but cannot compensate for a poor initial reception.

Impact Analysis:

The Highguard situation serves as a cautionary tale for indie game developers and platform holders alike. The controversy surrounding its Game Awards debut and subsequent launch highlights the importance of strategic marketing, community engagement, and technical accessibility.
If Highguard ultimately fails, it could erode confidence in hero shooter games. Furthermore, it may impact future relationships between developers and showcase events, potentially leading to more stringent vetting processes or a shift towards paid placements. It casts a shadow on Keighley’s judgment and may affect trust in the Game Awards as an impartial showcase.

Read More