Tue Jan 20 04:20:00 UTC 2026: Headline: Controversial Overtime Interception Fuels Bills’ Outrage After Playoff Loss to Broncos

The Story:
The Buffalo Bills are contesting a critical interception call during their 33-30 overtime loss to the Denver Broncos in the divisional round of the playoffs. With 7:55 remaining in overtime, Bills quarterback Josh Allen threw a pass to Brandin Cooks, which Broncos cornerback Ja’Quan McMillian contested as both players went to the ground. The on-field ruling was an interception, giving the Broncos possession, which they subsequently converted into a game-winning field goal.

The call has sparked widespread debate among former NFL players and officials, with many questioning whether it should have been ruled a catch or, at worst, an incomplete pass. Bills head coach Sean McDermott voiced his displeasure with the ruling, adding to the chorus of criticism.

Key Points:

  • The disputed play occurred with 7:55 left in overtime of the Bills-Broncos divisional playoff game.
  • Josh Allen’s pass to Brandin Cooks was ruled an interception after contested possession with Ja’Quan McMillian.
  • Former NFL players like Richard Sherman and Dan Orlovsky argued the play should have been ruled a catch.
  • Former Broncos player Shannon Sharpe and former NFL official Gene Steratore supported the interception call based on the NFL rulebook regarding maintaining possession through the act of the catch.
  • The article highlights an earlier play involving Aaron Rodgers where a similar catch was reviewed and overturned, raising questions about consistency in officiating.
  • NFL rules analyst Walt Anderson and former NFL official Terry McAulay agreed with the ruling on the field of an interception.

Critical Analysis:
N/A

Key Takeaways:

  • Subjectivity in applying NFL catch rules continues to create controversy and impact game outcomes.
  • Inconsistencies in officiating, as highlighted by the comparison to the Aaron Rodgers play, erode fan trust in the league’s integrity.
  • The NFL faces ongoing pressure to clarify and standardize catch rules to minimize subjective interpretations by officials.
  • Close scrutiny and instant replay are necessary to mitigate the impact of subjective calls made by officials.
  • Even with replays the rules are still open to interpretation and will continue to be a source of controversy.

    Read More