Sun Jan 04 08:00:00 UTC 2026: Summary:
The article discusses the trend of established actors trying their hand at directing, highlighting the challenges and varying degrees of success they encounter. It contrasts the muted reception of Kate Winslet’s directorial debut, “Goodbye June,” on Netflix, with the more celebrated premieres of films directed by Scarlett Johansson, Harris Dickinson, and particularly Kristen Stewart’s “The Chronology of Water.” The piece suggests that not all actors possess the skills to effectively translate their talent behind the camera, and Winslet’s film, while not a failure, lacks a compelling vision and feels unremarkable compared to Stewart’s more daring and successful directorial effort.
News Article:
Actor-Turned-Director: Kate Winslet’s Debut Fails to Make a Splash, While Kristen Stewart Dazzles
Hollywood is buzzing with the latest wave of actors stepping behind the camera, but the results are proving uneven. While some, like Kristen Stewart, are earning critical acclaim for their directorial debuts, others, like Kate Winslet, are finding the transition less than triumphant.
Winslet’s “Goodbye June,” a family drama starring herself, Helen Mirren, and Toni Collette, was quietly released on Netflix, a stark contrast to the splashy premieres enjoyed by Scarlett Johansson and Harris Dickinson at Cannes Film Festival with their directorial debuts “Eleanor the Great” and “Urchin,” respectively.
The underwhelming reception has raised questions about the often-romanticized notion of actors successfully transitioning to directing. The article points to the stark contrast between Winslet’s film and Kristen Stewart’s “The Chronology of Water,” a bold adaptation of Lidia Yuknavitch’s memoir, as a prime example of how not all actors can effectively translate their on-screen talent to behind-the-camera success.
“While ‘Goodbye June’ is far from a catastrophe,” the article states, “it’s perhaps a greater sin that the film would be far more interesting if it were.” It criticizes the film’s lack of a compelling vision and its reliance on familiar tropes, while praising Stewart’s debut for its raw atmosphere and confident directorial eye.
The piece concludes that while Winslet, like many actors-turned-directors, will likely get another chance, her first film has set a less-than-promising precedent. It suggests that a strong on-screen presence doesn’t always guarantee success behind the camera, and that a compelling vision is crucial for actors looking to make a lasting impact as directors.
First Piper 