Sun Sep 14 12:50:00 UTC 2025: ## Manchester Derby Goalkeeping Gamble: Donnarumma Debut for City? Amorim Trusts Bayindir for United

**Manchester, UK** – Both Manchester City and Manchester United are facing crucial goalkeeping decisions ahead of Sunday’s Manchester Derby, highlighting the rapid changes in football. Just weeks ago, managers Pep Guardiola and Ruben Amorim expressed contentment with their goalkeepers. Now, the narrative has drastically shifted.

Manchester City’s Guardiola is considering throwing new signing Gianluigi Donnarumma straight into the starting XI for his debut at the Etihad Stadium. The Italian’s arrival from Fenerbahce on deadline day, following Ederson’s move to Fenerbahce, raises questions about the fit with Guardiola’s tactics. While Donnarumma is a world-class shot-stopper, concerns linger regarding his proficiency with the ball at his feet compared to Ederson’s exceptional distribution abilities. Guardiola acknowledged this difference, stating he wouldn’t force Donnarumma to replicate Ederson’s play style. However, Guardiola also has the option of starting James Trafford, who returned to City this summer.

On the other side of the divide, Manchester United manager Ruben Amorim has opted to start Altay Bayindir over fellow summer signing Senne Lammens in goal for the Red Devils. Amorim justified the decision by stating Bayindir has more experience than Lammens. This decision comes after a turbulent period for United’s goalkeeping situation. André Onana, expected to be the starter, was surprisingly left out of several games, and eventually loaned to Trabzonspor, paving the way for Bayindir.

Bayindir, who has looked shaky at times, will face immense pressure in the derby. Any mistake against City is likely to fuel the calls for Lammens to be given a chance, despite United viewing him as a long-term project rather than an immediate solution.

Both goalkeeping choices underscore the high stakes of the Manchester Derby, with potential debutants facing a baptism of fire under intense scrutiny. The goalkeepers at both ends of the pitch are sure to be one of the biggest talking points of the afternoon.

Read More