Wed May 07 18:50:00 UTC 2025: **Former FBI Agent Suggests San Clemente Island as Alternative to Alcatraz for New Supermax Prison**
WASHINGTON, D.C. – President Donald Trump’s proposal to reopen Alcatraz as a supermax prison for America’s most violent criminals has sparked debate, with former FBI Special Agent Jonathan Gilliam suggesting an alternative location: San Clemente Island.
Trump, in a Truth Social post, called for the “rebuilding and opening” of Alcatraz, stating it would serve as a symbol of law and order. While legal experts note the feasibility of reopening Alcatraz, they also predict potential legal challenges.
Gilliam, however, believes San Clemente Island, a U.S. Navy-controlled island off the coast of California, offers a superior alternative. Its remote location, accessible only by boat or air, would create a formidable deterrent, he argues. The island’s size and isolation, Gilliam contends, would make it a more effective and potentially less costly option than renovating Alcatraz.
“Just the isolation of it would send shock factors through the minds of a lot of these people,” Gilliam told Fox News Digital. He added that the island’s remoteness evokes the same sense of inescapable confinement that made Alcatraz notorious.
Trump’s plan focuses on housing “America’s most ruthless and violent offenders,” reflecting his broader stance on law and order. His statement emphasized a return to stricter incarceration policies for serious criminals. The former president’s call for the reopening of the prison, closed in 1963, has reignited the conversation about the appropriate measures for handling the nation’s most dangerous offenders.
First Piper 