Sat Apr 26 01:40:00 UTC 2025: ## Fantasy Baseball Busts and Booms: Week 3 Closer Report

**New York, NY** – The fantasy baseball season is off to a chaotic start, with several high-profile closers experiencing dramatic shifts in performance and value. While some are proving their worth, others have left fantasy managers scrambling to find replacements.

Devin Williams, a highly touted Yankees closer acquired this winter, has seen a significant drop in roster percentages after a recent blown save. While a high BABIP (.423) suggests bad luck rather than a decline in skill, his performance has raised concerns. However, analysts suggest that his struggles are unsustainable and recommend holding onto him.

Other closers are defying expectations. Jeff Hoffman of the Toronto Blue Jays has been a revelation, converting all five save opportunities. Kyle Finnegan of the Washington Nationals continues his strong save streak, despite less-than-stellar peripherals. Justin Martinez of the Arizona Diamondbacks is poised for increased save opportunities following A.J. Puk’s injury. Jose Alvarado of the Philadelphia Phillies has emerged as the team’s closer following Jordan Romano’s disastrous outing. Justin Slaten of the Boston Red Sox is another standout, though he shares save opportunities with Aroldis Chapman.

Meanwhile, Felix Bautista of the Baltimore Orioles and Lucas Erceg of the Kansas City Royals are underperforming relative to expectations, prompting many fantasy managers to drop them. Bautista’s recovery from Tommy John surgery is impacting his performance, while Erceg’s role might be limited to setup. Alexis Diaz of the Cincinnati Reds continues to struggle, making his path to consistent saves unclear. The Minnesota Twins bullpen, featuring Jax, Duran, and Sands, is also underperforming due to the team’s overall struggles, impacting the fantasy value of all three. While Jax is considered droppable, Duran remains a hold.

In short, Week 3 of the fantasy baseball season has highlighted the unpredictable nature of relief pitching. While some high-profile players are experiencing temporary setbacks, others are emerging as unexpected stars. Careful monitoring and shrewd decision-making will be key for fantasy managers navigating these shifting landscapes.

Read More