Sat Mar 01 02:10:00 UTC 2025: ## Husband Convicted of Murdering Two Wives in Suspicious Falls
**Denver, CO** – A new ABC 20/20 episode, “Mountain of Lies,” airing Friday, details the shocking case of Harold Henthorn, convicted of murdering his second wife, Toni Henthorn, in Rocky Mountain National Park in 2012. The investigation revealed a pattern of suspicious deaths and financial manipulation spanning decades.
Toni Henthorn, an ophthalmologist, died after falling from a cliff during a celebratory anniversary trip with her husband. Initial reports suggested an accident, but inconsistencies in Harold’s account and a deeper dive into his past led to a chilling revelation.
Investigators uncovered a disturbing history. Harold’s first wife, Lynn, died in 1995 under similarly unusual circumstances, initially ruled an accident. Both deaths occurred in remote locations, with Harold escaping injury in each instance. These similarities, along with anonymous letters highlighting Lynn’s death, spurred a thorough investigation.
The investigation revealed Harold’s extensive deception. He falsely claimed to be a certified fundraiser, lacked verifiable employment history, and had amassed significant life insurance payouts following both his wives’ deaths – $600,000 after Lynn’s death and $4.5 million in policies on Toni. Further, he attempted to secure a large life insurance policy on his sister-in-law, attempting to list himself as the sole beneficiary. He also exerted extreme control over his daughter, Haley, isolating her from her extended family.
Evidence showed Harold manipulated his wives’ finances and controlled Haley’s life following Toni’s death. This, coupled with inconsistencies surrounding the circumstances of both deaths, led to his arrest and subsequent conviction for first-degree murder in Toni’s death in 2015. He received a life sentence without parole. While Harold was never charged in Lynn’s death, the case remains closed as an accident.
Haley Henthorn Bertolet, Toni’s daughter, now adopted by her maternal uncle and aunt, shared her story in her first interview since her mother’s death. She recounted her father’s controlling behavior and expressed forgiveness, not for his sake, but to free herself from his influence. The 20/20 episode promises a gripping account of this complex and disturbing case.
First Piper 