Sun Feb 09 11:04:14 UTC 2025: ## FA Cup VAR Controversy: Absent Technology Fuels Debate After Weekend of Controversial Calls

**London, England** – The absence of Video Assistant Referee (VAR) technology in the fourth round of the FA Cup has sparked significant controversy, with several contentious incidents dominating post-match discussions. While some managers, like Brighton’s Fabian Hurzeler, welcomed the return to a more “emotional” game without VAR’s intervention, others criticized the lack of clarity and consistency.

Several key incidents highlighted the debate:

* **Leyton Orient vs. Manchester City:** Leyton Orient’s stunning long-range goal, which briefly put them ahead of Manchester City, is under dispute. City protested, claiming a foul in the build-up. The absence of VAR prevented a review.

* **Manchester United vs. Leicester City:** Harry Maguire’s late, decisive goal for Manchester United was clearly offside, but the error went uncorrected due to the lack of VAR.

* **Brighton vs. Chelsea:** A potential handball in the build-up to Brighton’s winning goal went unpunished, leading to Chelsea’s frustration.

* **Birmingham City vs. Newcastle United:** Joe Willock’s goal was awarded despite uncertainty over whether the ball had fully crossed the line. The lack of goal-line technology (present in some but not all venues) amplified the debate.

The FA’s decision to exclude VAR from the fourth round, citing infrastructure costs and the need for consistent refereeing across all participating clubs, has come under scrutiny. While goalline technology was available at some venues, the inconsistent application of technology further complicated the situation.

The differing opinions among managers, players, and pundits reflect the deep divisions over VAR’s role in the game. While some see it as a necessary tool for accuracy, others argue it removes the emotional intensity and inherent uncertainty of football. The fourth-round matches have starkly highlighted the ongoing debate surrounding the use of technology in football, prompting calls for clarification and consistency in its implementation across all FA Cup rounds.

Read More