Tue Jan 14 02:50:00 UTC 2025: ## Netflix’s Gritty Western “American Primeval” Tops Charts, Sparks Debate

**New York, NY** – Mark L. Smith’s (“The Revenant”) new Netflix series, “American Primeval,” has stormed to the top of the streaming charts. This six-episode limited series, a collaboration between Peter Berg and Taylor Kitsch, depicts the brutal struggle for power in pre-Civil War Utah and Wyoming. The show, known for its relentlessly grim aesthetic (even excluding birdsong from the soundtrack), presents a stark vision of the American West as a chaotic and violent landscape.

The series follows interwoven narratives surrounding the 1857-58 Utah War. A Victorian woman (Betty Gilpin) and her son, guided by a grizzled mountain man (Taylor Kitsch), journey across treacherous terrain pursued by a bounty hunter (Jai Courtney). Their journey intersects with a Mormon couple’s desperate search for each other (Dane DeHaan and Saura Lightfoot-Leon), the conflict between frontiersman Jim Bridger (Shea Wigham) and Brigham Young (Kim Coates), and the struggles of a US Army captain (Lucas Neff) to maintain peace.

While the series features numerous storylines—perhaps to its detriment—it tackles the Mountain Meadows Massacre, a pivotal event in the Utah War. However, the show significantly downplays the massacre’s brutality compared to historical accounts. While the show depicts violence, it avoids the prolonged siege and systematic extermination of the Baker-Fancher wagon train, instead focusing on the perspective of a surviving emigrant.

Creator Mark L. Smith defends this approach, aiming to represent “both sides” of the conflict, including showcasing the Mormon militia’s perspective and historical grievances. He incorporates Brigham Young’s actual words and highlights anti-Mormon prejudice.

Despite the series’ ambition, critics question its originality, noting that the “violent West” theme is hardly novel. While “American Primeval” offers a visually stunning and intensely violent exploration of the period, its numerous storylines and somewhat sanitized depiction of the Mountain Meadows Massacre leave some wondering if it truly adds a fresh perspective to the well-trodden Western genre.

Read More