Mon Dec 30 20:12:18 UTC 2024: ## Controversial Dismissal of Jaiswal Fuels Debate Over DRS Technology in India-Australia Test

**Melbourne, Australia** – The fourth day of the second Test between India and Australia was marred by a controversial dismissal that has ignited a debate about the reliability of Decision Review System (DRS) technology. Young Indian batsman Yashasvi Jaiswal, on 84, was given out caught behind off Pat Cummins, a decision that sparked considerable debate.

While replays showed a clear deflection off Jaiswal’s glove, Snicko, the audio technology used for DRS, failed to pick up any sound of the edge. This absence of audio evidence, despite visual evidence of a deflection, left Jaiswal visibly frustrated and led to a lengthy wait while the third umpire reviewed the decision.

Third umpire Paul Reiffel ultimately ruled Jaiswal out, basing his decision on the visible deflection. However, this decision has drawn criticism, with many questioning the use of Snicko if the visual evidence alone is sufficient for a conclusive decision.

Former international umpire Simon Taufel defended the decision, stating that a clear deflection is sufficient evidence for an out ruling, even without supporting audio. Indian captain Rohit Sharma acknowledged a possible touch but expressed concerns over the inconsistency of the technology. Pat Cummins, while confident of the dismissal, admitted the technology’s limitations.

Adding to the controversy, Snicko’s operator, Warren Brennan, explained the absence of audio spike as a result of the type of shot played, indicating that only HotSpot, a technology not in use this series due to cost and operational issues in hot weather, could have provided conclusive evidence.

Cricket legend Sunil Gavaskar questioned the purpose of using Snicko if its evidence isn’t fully trusted. This incident underscores the ongoing challenges in utilizing technology to make accurate and fair decisions in cricket matches and highlights the need for a more robust and reliable system. India ultimately lost the match by 184 runs.

Read More