Sun Nov 03 03:50:00 UTC 2024: ## “Conclave” Sparks Controversy: Is It a Takedown of the Catholic Church or a Humanist Exploration?
Director Edward Berger’s new film “Conclave,” currently in theaters, follows the secretive process of selecting a new pope. While the film depicts the internal struggles and scandals of the candidates, Berger insists it is not a “takedown” of the Catholic Church, but rather an exploration of human nature.
The film, based on Robert Harris’ novel, has sparked debate, with some accusing it of being “anti-Catholic propaganda.” Conservative commentator Ben Shapiro called the film “evil” and claimed it promotes a progressive agenda.
However, Berger maintains that the film is not a condemnation of the Church but an attempt to portray its members as “humans.” “Humans make mistakes,” he told Yahoo Entertainment. “They have problems and are weighed down by their conscience.”
He welcomes the controversy, stating that it promotes open discussion and encourages different perspectives. “If everyone has a different opinion and a different feeling, that’s a good thing,” he said.
Ralph Fiennes, who plays Cardinal Lawrence, acknowledged the intrigue surrounding secretive worlds like conclaves, noting their “ancient” rituals and hidden nature. He believes this mystery fuels audience curiosity and allows for a dramatic exploration of the characters’ internal struggles.
Berger hopes audiences connect with Lawrence’s journey of faith and self-discovery, stating, “If people go through this journey with him, I’m really happy.”
The film’s release has ignited a conversation about the Catholic Church and its portrayal in popular media, prompting viewers to consider the complexities of faith, power, and human nature. Whether “Conclave” is a critique of the Church or a humanizing portrayal, its impact on audiences and its potential to spark dialogue on important issues is undeniable.
First Piper 