Wed Sep 25 08:40:23 UTC 2024: ## Laapataa Ladies Selected as India’s Oscar Entry Amidst Controversy
**Mumbai, India -** Wildlife film-maker Subbiah Nalla Muthu, a member of the Film Federation of India jury that selected India’s entry to the Oscars for Best International Film, has defended the choice of Kiran Rao’s “Laapataa Ladies” amidst criticism.
Muthu insists that the film was not chosen as the “best” film in India, but rather as the most likely to resonate with the Western jury. He explains that out of 29 entries, the jury unanimously chose “Laapataa Ladies” based on its potential to capture the attention of international audiences.
“Everyone should understand that Laapataa Ladies is not the only best film in India. It is one of the best films out of these 29 entries,” Muthu told Subhash K Jha. “Every member of the jury had to compare those 29, and they unanimously selected Laapataa Ladies.”
Muthu also addressed the controversy surrounding the exclusion of “All We Imagine As Light”, stating that the jury members felt it was too similar to a French film and lacked the necessary appeal for international recognition.
He stressed that the Oscar selection process is not just about quality, but also about strategic considerations like lobbying and financial potential. He also pointed out that the film “Undercurrent” (Ullozhukku), a Malayalam film, was also considered a strong contender.
Muthu further clarified that any film can enter the Oscars directly, and that the Film Federation’s selection does not preclude other films from competing. However, he emphasized the financial implications of such an endeavor, citing the example of “RRR” which spent millions on promoting its Oscar campaign.
He also highlighted the fact that the Federation does not automatically choose films, and that producers should be aware of the process and the associated costs.
“People should know that anyone can apply, and they need to pay money,” he said.
Muthu also expressed surprise at the absence of entries from Karnataka and Bengal this year, suggesting that more awareness about the Oscar selection process is needed.
First Piper 